Tonnage Calculation's Impact on Cost Control

Posted by Al Timm on Jan 24, 2017 9:08:00 AM

tonnage-calculation.jpgInjection molding is a complex, dynamic system with multiple, interacting factors—all of which impact performance, cost, and quality. One of these factors is the tonnage calculation, also known as the clamping force of the injection molding machine.

The “tonnage” is the measure of force that is required to keep the mold closed during the injection process. This force is the main factor in determining the machine size required for producing the part. This may seem pretty straightforward, but a lot rides on an accurate determination of tonnage, and as such, working with an experienced molder is critical to producing complex plastic components.

Impact of Improper Tonnage

A clamping force that is too low will likely lead to inconsistent results or defects, including variable size and weight, flash, short shots, wall thickness variations, and irregular surface finish. Too much clamping force can reduce the life of a mold by adding unnecessary wear and tear, which ultimately increases production costs to rebuild the tool more frequently.

Machines that deliver high clamping forces are more expensive than machines that deliver lower clamping forces, and a less experienced or commodity molder may not have the right size machine for your project. Plastics engineers at a complex injection molder can accurately calculate tonnage, ensuring the right-sized machine is used and eliminating the risk for overclamping.

Not sure what type of injection molder you need? Download our comparison tool.

[Free Guide] What Type of Injection Molder Do You Need?

Cutting Costs with Tonnage Calculation

A tonnage calculation is often presented as a range (for example, from 550 tons to 1,300 tons for a single-cavity tool). An injection molder can certainly save money by purchasing a smaller machine that can deliver the lowest clamping force in the range and claiming it will do the job just fine. However, if the optimum tonnage calculation is actually in the mid-to-upper part of the range, this increases the risk to you, the manufaturer, that your plastic parts will have flash (which occurs when the mold opens slightly during injection) because the machine lacks sufficient clamping force to produce a flash-free part.   

Molders still often estimate tonnage by using a “rule of thumb” equation that involves the area of the part, type of plastic, viscosity, and a “clamp factor” that ranges from 2 to 8. Depending on the part and type of material, some molders simply go with an “average” clamping factor of 5 to calculate the tonnage.

This approach can result in an inaccurate tonnage calculation that is too small (resulting in quality problems and delays) or is too large (resulting in increased mold costs and premature deterioration).

A more accurate way to determine the tonnage calculation is through moldflow analysis, which removes much of the guesswork from the calculation. It’s been our experience that using moldflow analysis to determine the tonnage factor, and then adding a “safety factor” of about 15 percent, results in a highly accurate clamping force and flash-free parts.

Moldflow Analysis' Effect 

Moldflow analysis is also an effective method for determining the impact of other production variables, such as number of gates (more gates will lower tonnage requirements) and flow length (longer flow lengths require higher pressures and therefore a higher tonnage).

Using moldflow analysis early in the design process also helps determine the best gating scheme for the mold. Typically, after a mold is designed, it is tested in a certain-sized tonnage press. If flash occurs, it is tested in the next-highest press.

Be cautious of the flow simulation analysis software you use, as it may only provide the pressure needed to fill the part—it may not always include the pressure during the pack phase. This can be a drawbacktonnage requirements are also a function of the pressure required to fill or pack the part. It is often easy to fill the part when using easy-flowing material like nylon—in these cases, flow simulation analysis software will show low pressure. However, this cannot be used for the tonnage calculation because the higher packing pressure still needs to be applied to eliminate sink. If the packing pressure is higher than fill pressure, it must be accounted for in the tonnage calculation.

There are many variables that go into calculating an accurate tonnage that can heavily impact the quality and profitability of your plastic parts. Having the right injection molding partner is key to ensure these calculations are measured correctly to set your project up for long-term sucess. Complex injection molders who are skilled in a scientific molding approach are able to optimize the entire process before defects occur. Learn more in our free whitepaper — click the button below to get your copy.

Scientific Molding: A Molder's Perspective  

Topics: Injection Molding